Showing posts with label RAW. Show all posts
Showing posts with label RAW. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 19, 2010

India: Power or Downfall

One of the major causes that led to the First World War was Emperor William's ambitions for the German Empire to be a world power. He believed in an uncompromising policy of 'power or downfall' which ultimately resulted in the 'downfall' of the empire. Similarly, it is the misfortune of South Asia that India has been trying to endanger the region's peace by aspiring to become a 'world power', or at least a 'regional power' in wake of modern world trends like renunciation of war, peaceful settlement of disputes and economic development.
Over the years, India has not only been developing its conventional and nuclear arsenals, but is also obtaining latest weapons from the US, Russia and Israel in violation of the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT). In this context, presuming a peace-loving China as an enemy New Delhi often justifies arms accumulation, while in practice India has constantly deployed its forces along the Pakistani border. As regards Indian belligerent approach, it is the result of India's shattered hope of intimidating other neighbouring countries, especially Pakistan which the former considers a continuous obstacle in the way of its designs.
Under the pretext of Talibinisation, the Indian secret agency, RAW, has well established its tentacles in Afghanistan, and has been running secret operations against Pakistan from its consulates located near the Pak-Afghan border. It has spent millions of dollars in Afghanistan to strengthen its grip in order to get strategic depth against Islamabad.
Meanwhile, PM Gilani and FM Qureshi have repeatedly stated: "India supports terrorism in Pakistan, and its evidence will be shown to the western countries at the right occasion." Indeed, this is in coordination with the statements of the ISPR spokesman Major General Athar Abbas who revealed that during the ongoing military operations huge cache of arms and ammunition had been captured while it was being shifted from Afghanistan.
Perhaps, frustrated in achieving its aims of becoming a world power, and a permanent seat in the UNSC, now the Indian rulers have started openly threatening nuclear powers like Pakistan and China. In this backdrop, the Indian Army Chief, General Deepak Kapoor, vocally revealed on December 29 that the Indian army "is now revising its five-year old doctrine" and is preparing for a "possible two-front war with China and Pakistan."
However in response to New Delhi's threat, Pakistan's JCSC chairman, General Tariq Majeed, stated: "The Indian army chief's statement exhibits a lack of strategic acumen...[such a path could] fix India on a self-destructive mechanism."
It is surprising to note that in more than seven states, India itself faces separatist movements which are the result of acute poverty and social injustices. Particularly, Maoist movement that has been raging in West Bengal, and has now expanded to other regions including Maharashtra. At present, it is a popular insurgency by the downtrodden who have massive support of the people for their ideology. On October 31 last year, the New York Times wrote: "India's Maoist rebels are now present in 20 states and have killed more than 900 Indian security officers...India's rapid economic growth has made it an emerging global power but also deepened stark inequalities in society." Thus, by neglecting all these ground realties New Delhi has been advancing towards a self-destructive path.
Notably, USA's dependence on Pakistan for war against terrorism and for close economic cooperation with China will roll back the Indian clandestine agenda which is part of its regional ambition against Islamabad and Beijing. Nonetheless, like the failed foreign policy of Emperor William II, the Indian policy of 'power or downfall' is bound to result in a nuclear catastrophe in the region as 'nuclearised' Pakistan and China cannot ignore their defence, while their adversary is determined to act upon its aggressive designs.
He writes on international affairs and is author of the book: US vs Islamic Militants, Invisible Balance of Power: Dangerous Shift in International Affairs. Source: http://www.markthetruth.com/pakistan-a-the-world/297-india-power-or-downfall.html

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

India's N-doctrine dangerous, offensive: Pakistan

ISLAMABAD – Arch-rivals India and Pakistan are back to a cold war like situation with the dialogue process between the two neighbours taking a back seat, thanks to irresponsible Indian attitude, Hindu extremism and expansionist designs.
 
The two major South Asian powers that have fought three wars and were on the brink of a nuclear war in 1999 are back to 'Cold war' like situation following series of irresponsible statements by the Indian Prime Minister and Indian Army Chief.
Pakistan perceived the Indian Army Chief General Deepak Kapoor's yesterday's statement as a warning for nuclear war. Deepak said on Monday "A limited war under a nuclear overhang is still very much a reality, at least in the Indian sub-continent."
 
Spokesperson of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said that these remarks only reaffirm India's dangerous and offensive nuclear doctrine.
 
India has long been working on the so-called 'Cold Start' strategy and preparing for a limited war against Pakistan. General Kapoor's statement confirms the hegemonic thrust of India's nuclear doctrine, Abdul Basit said on Tuesday.
"The international community should take notice of General Kapoor's remarks and India's long-term intentions", Basit suggested.
 
He also said that Pakistan is fully capable of safeguarding its national sovereignty and defending its borders. However, as a responsible country, we will continue promoting peace and stability in South Asia on the basis of equality and mutual respect. The "peace process" between the two countries came to a halt after the 26/11 terror strikes in the Indian business capital Mumbai. Since 26/11, dialogue process has not resumed despite several sincere attempts from Pakistan. The heads of state of India and Pakistan have met twice. During the talks between Indian and Pakistani premiers Manmohan Singh and Syed Yousuf Raza Gilani at Sharm El Sheikh in Egypt, the two countries came out with a joint statement de-linking dialogue with terrorism and including the Balochistan issue. This generated hope that the two countries would restart the dialogue process.
 
However, to the shock and disappointment of peace-loving Pakistanis, India has is dragging the sub-continent back to 'cold war' era, many think.
 
According to experts, the joint India-Pakistan statement came under sharp criticism from the Indian opposition parties, especially right wing Hindu party BJP, who felt that the Balochistan reference and de-linking terrorism from dialogue process was a 'defeat' of Indian diplomacy.
 
Following sharp criticism and after being cornered at the home-turf, the Indian Government hardened its stand vis-a-vis resumption of dialogue process with Pakistan and linked the restart of peace process with Pakistan's action against 'terrorist elements'.
 
Pakistan has several times conveyed to India that the stalling of dialogue process between the two countries is benefiting the terrorists.
 
The 'cold war' like situation between India and Pakistan will not be in the interest of any of the two countries. Instead it gives an opportunity to extremist elements to prove that 'force' is the only relevant means to resolve the outstanding issues between the two countries, many think
 
 

Friday, July 10, 2009

Nuclear deterrence keeps our adversaries at bay

By Asif Haroon Raja
 
Front row: Pakistani President Muhammad Zia ul-Haq (left) and President Carter (right). Zbigniew Brzezinski is in the center of the back rowIn pursuant of its stated objectives, India dismembered Pakistan into two in 1971. Basking in the sunshine of glory it embarked upon an ambitious force modernization program and also carried out weapon grade nuclear test at Pokhran in 1974 to become unchallenged regional power. RAW had a hand in KGB-KHAD supported insurgency in Balochistan in 1970s.. Sindh was picked up as the prime target for subversion on the model of East Pakistan. RAW supported Al-Zulfiqar in 1980s and also helped MQM in forming its militant wing to accentuate rural-urban divide in Sindh. The world took no notice of all these threatening events endangering the very existence of Pakistan. Taking into account the military balance tilting heavily towards India and its inability to bridge the widening conventional gap, Pakistan was left with no option but to go nuclear to avert 1971 like tragedy. Unlike India pilfering nuclear material from Canadian nuclear reactor installed at Tarapur and getting away with it, Pakistan undertook the nuclear path at its own, without foreign assistance and under immense adversity. Dr AQ Khan led team of scientists achieved the miracle of producing enriched uranium in about six years time, which helped in turning Pakistan into first Muslim nuclear state. Huge resources at the cost of vital development works had to be diverted towards this clandestinely run project and the nation bore economic hardships gladly since it was question of survival of the country.
 
Evers since, Pakistan nuclear program has come under immense censure. All possible means were applied to knock it down in its infancy stage. Hats off to those who were at the helm of affairs; they bore the onslaught stoically and not for once wavered. Pakistan made another landmark in the field of guided missiles and produced better delivery systems than India. It’s Command and Control Authority (C&CA) too is much superior to that of India and matches any nuclear state. In the wake of malicious propaganda warfare launched by Indo-US-Israeli lobbies against safety of our nuclear program, Pakistan has further fine-tuned its security systems and taken added measures to leave no scope for theft. It has gone to the extent of keeping warheads and delivery means separated and stored in different locations. Nuclear doctrine hinging on credible minimum deterrence, spells out threshold beyond which use of nuclear option becomes inevitable and also keeps its first strike option. It is only when conventional forces are unable to contain ingress of invading forces that nuclear option come into play and not otherwise.
 
It is this fear of use of WMDs which pose caution on the enemy. This fright that the invasion would become extremely costly in terms of human casualties has kept India at bay. 1985-86 troop mobilization (Exercise Brass-tacks), 1990-91 heat up along Kashmir border, May-July 1999 skirmish in Kargil, 2002 and 2007 military standoffs, all had likelihood of ballooning into full-fledged war. As a minimum these offensive acts were meant to overawe Pakistan. However, on each occasion when Indian leaders were breathing fire and itched to decimate Pakistan, Pakistan armed forces showed its full resolve to fight the invaders and also brandished its nuclear weapons which took the heat of belligerence out of them. No other means employed had any impact on jingoism of Indian leaders bordering madness. The planned Indo-Israeli surgical strikes against Kahuta Plant in 1980s and in May 1998 after Indian nuclear tests were also averted due to dread of nuclear reaction.
 
From 1979 till May 1998, our nuclear deterrence worked by following policy of ambiguity. Only reason for India to carryout overt nuclear tests in May 1998 was to see whether Pakistan actually had the nuclear capability or it was bluffing. Our tit-for-tat response cooled down fire-eating Advani and Jaswant Singh and their tone and tenor changed. It was essentially because of our impressive progress in the fields of nuclear and missile technology which forced India to abandon its strategy of direct war and instead adopt indirect strategy to destabilize Pakistan from within. This strategy had also been successfully applied in former East Pakistan before applying the military instrument.
 
Bin Laden, dressed in combat fatigues, in Afghanistan during the 1980's. (Note the image has been digitally altered to brighten the shadow on his face.)India is desperate to offset Pakistan's nuclear deterrence capability since it pours cold water on its expansionist designs. One way is to build up its stockpiles of both strategic and tactical nuclear bombs far outmatching Pakistan’s modest stock. In this regard, Indo-US civilian nuclear deal would give a quantum jump to its nuclear ambitions. It has developed second strike capability and is working on achieving third strike capability as well. It is stock piling low yield tactical nuclear bombs and has produced wide array of missiles including sea-borne cruise missiles. Israel has become its biggest arms supplier and is also cooperating in the nuclear field. AWACs, anti-missile systems, electronic means and spy satellite have recently been procured from Israel. India being a strategic partner of USA is a hot candidate for becoming part of US defence shield.
 
In the wake of nuclear threat from Pakistan, India has conceived a new doctrine called Cold Start in which mobilization period has been cut to three days and war is declared suddenly. Mobile forces leap for tactically important shallow objectives within the border belt under air supremacy and stay clear of core areas so as not to give an excuse to Pakistan to use its nuclear option. The idea is that Pakistan already suffering from lack of strategic depth can ill-afford to lose space. As such, it would be compelled to fight major battles with bulk of its forces along the border and thus presenting a vulnerable target to air and small tactical nuclear weapons, usage of which is authorized to operational commander in the field. This option has also been made dependent upon the success of its preparatory maneuver in the form of covert operations by RAW to soften Pakistan from within as it is currently doing unabashedly.
 
In the face of Indian Cold Start doctrine which India is eager to launch, our nuclear weapons should be in assembled and ready form rather than in dispersed and disassembled state with delivery means separated from warheads and stored in different locations. This has been done merely to satisfy overweening Americans concerned about safety of our nuclear weapons not realizing that it runs against the principles of deterrence and operational preparedness. This arrangement as a safety measure was in order had it been done secretly without anyone else knowing about it. If not all, at least one-fourth of weapons should be in state of readiness both for deterrence and to cater for element of surprise.
 
Khan Research Laboratories in KahutaAnti-nuclear lobbyists like Pervez Hoodhbuoy and Farrukh Saleem who sing dictated tunes that nuclear bomb is a liability and not a strategic asset should be ignored. The 45-year Cold War between the two super powers didn't turn into Third World War because each side had credible nuclear deterrence. Had Afghanistan and Iraq possessed nuclear weapons, USA would never have dared to attack. Iraq was invaded only when US leaders became 100% sure that it was not in possession of WMDs. IAEA inspectors had sniffed each and every nook of Iraq and had given all clear signal. So was the case with non-nuclear North Korea in 1953 and Vietnam. North Korea and Iran are not being touched despite their belligerence since former is now a nuclear power with long range ballistic missiles and latter is suspected to have already crossed the threshold. Pakistan was spared in October 2001 and till this day because of its nuclear capability. These live examples are ample proofs that nuclear weapons are best suited for weaker nations threatened by bullies. Our nuclear doctrine based on credible minimum deterrence and first strike option has helped in keeping our adversaries at bay.

Wednesday, July 08, 2009

Nuclear Iran: A Headache or a Heal? - IV

by Sohail Parwaz
 
In my first column on this subject I wrote, "Interestingly, the issues on which the US, France, and the UK are making a hue and cry were once hatched and sponsored by them. How could one forget that it was the US Secretary of State Henry Kissinger who had signed the National Security Decision Memorandum that very generously laid out the niceties of the sale of nuclear energy equipment to Iran?" I still maintain my words that the baseless and bogus logic given now by the US and the Western world are not acceptable to the world. I would insist upon my earlier saying why the logic given now did not strike the astute Americans at that time when, out of sheer sincerity and love, they were equipping the Iranians with their first ever (US-supplied) 5-megawatt nuclear research reactor in 1967. The fact is that the 'love-lost story' is of pre-9/11 era. All this botheration started after the falling of the Twin Towers when Bush junior vowed to fight the 'Crusade'.
 
Since 2002, the US is adamant about Iran's need for nuclear power and for that the gauche argument given is that, firstly, Iran has copious oil reserves and secondly, nuclear power is more expensive to generate than oil power.  Ironically, no one dares to ask the US to start the implication of this idea from home as they also have plentiful and untouched oil reserves. Since the last six years the US is unlawfully and unethically flying UAVs (unmanned aerial vehicles) over Iran to obtain sensitive information about Iran's nuclear programme but to their disappointment they have not been able to get much out of it. This made them more furious since they are not finding any opportunity to cut loose hell upon the Iranians.
 
If we go into little details and make some attempt to investigate we will find that the reason for developing a stand-off between the US and Iran over nuclear technology was due to two fallacies on the part of both, the Iranians as well as the Americans. The Iranians had a misapprehension that their persistence for their right as a member of the IAEA to civilian nuclear energy followed by opening all their nuclear energy installations for inspection by the IAEA would finally melt the US's heart and it would cheerfully accept their right. And then the rest of the West will follow. They knew from the beginning that the Americans were after them and were trying to prevent them from completing the projects the Shah had started, as they did with other industrial projects in Iran.
 
Though many hardliners still believed that, "Americans cannot do a damn thing" as Khomeini had said, however, in the heart of their hearts they knew that the Americans will put pressure on them for political concessions. On the other hand, the Europeans and Americans had an erroneous belief that the Iranians will never be able to master the sophisticated technology due to lack of scientists and managers that had left Iran after the Islamic Revolution. So, they believed nothing will happen even if they let the Iranians do whatever investment they wanted in the nuclear field. They were of the view that at the end of the day the Iranians will turn to the West for help and then again they can coerce them for political dconcessions. The second delusion was the US and the West's wrong notions about their might. They had a wrong thinking about intervening diplomatically or militarily at any stage and stopping the Iranians even if they were getting close to "the red line" (enriching uranium). They were wrongly dreaming to cause humiliation to the Iranians and make them dance to their tune.
 
However, a potential reason behind the US resistance lies in the Middle Eastern geopolitics. The US deems it fit to guard against the slightest possibility of Iran obtaining nuclear weapons capability as it could easily take the West's sleep away. They are baselessly having an Iran phobia that compels them to maintain double standards for Iran vis-à-vis Israel. They believe that Iran, or for that matter any Muslim nuclear state, is more likely to ignite a conflict against Israel than Israel with Iran or the rest of the Muslim world. The notion that Muslim and especially Iranian or Pakistani nuclear weapons could eventually find their way into the hands of Islamic militants who would have fewer ethics about using them than a national state is deliberately propagated.
 
This burning issue does not seem likely to end peacefully and is more likely to remain unresolved as long as the American administration remains hypocritical about Iran and will mull over it with altogether different standards than it has for Israel, India, or even itself. What the US preaches to others must start from home first. Before expecting from Iran to fully adhere to the rules set forth in the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), Washington must do the same at home as well. This treaty is not merely meant for Iran or any other country. It requires the US and other nuclear powers that are parties to the treaty to enter into sincere and trusted parleys to achieve nuclear disarmament. But the irony is that the US is not doing so.
 
About a couple of years back, in a high-powered Washington dinner party where late Benazir was present along with Scowcroft, Brzezinski, and many others, a show of hands (16 hands!) suggested that Bush was headed to military action and only two 'innocents', including Scowcroft, were of the opinion that he would hold his fire. I was also of the opinion that a 'fanatic and radical' who felt an intense obligation to do all he could before exiting the Oval Office in 2009 would certainly use force to eliminate threats to 'American security', especially when according to him the diplomatic channels were not capable to resolve the Iran problem peacefully but I am not shy to cofess that I was wrong (for the time being). Such channels will merely allow Tehran to buy time for building weapons. Any american president, Bush or Obama, is stubborn to some extent and quite capable of taking risks and, if necessary, enduring consequences. Hence, there is no way of avoiding the conclusion (as far as I think) that the real goal of the US is to dismantle Iran's nuclear infrastructure, regardless of its orientation, and to dispatch Iran to the era of nuclear, scientific, and technological illiteracy, that is in violation of the letter and spirit of the NPT.
 
The only option left with Iran is to effectively present its case for attaining nuclear energy before the world while having 'a hardliner-like' Ahmadenijad in the chair. The clock is ticking and the countdown has already started. Though no one knows for whom the bell would toll, but one thing is clear that the US is determined to turn Iran back into Persia.