Monday, July 27, 2009

Does international law permit Tipaimukh Project?


By Dr. Asif Nazrul

According to the website of the North Eastern Electric Power Corporation Limited (NEEPCO) which is in charge of the Tipaimukh Project, this project will be one of the largest Hydro Electric Project in Eastern India to date and will be located 500 meters downstream of the confluence of the Tuivai and Barak Rivers in the District of Churachanpur in the State of Manipur. All statutory clearances, except forest clearance have been obtained and the project is scheduled for commissioning in 87 months time from date of CCEA Clearance.

Situated in a highly seismic zone, this project was seriously objected by the Bangladeshi experts as documented in the JRC's commentaries in 1985 on the updated Indian proposal for augmenting the flows of the Ganges submitted to Bangladesh in 1983. After that successive Bangladeshi governments have objected to the Tipaimukh project in view of its serious environmental and economic impact in the downstream. If India sticks to its original plan of constructing a Barrage at Fulertol or elsewhere to divert the water stored in the Tipaimukh the impact would be a reminiscent of the Farakka Debacle. It may be mentioned here that In the 36th meeting of the Joint River Commission held from 19 to 21 September, 2005, Bangladesh asked whether, instead of Phulertol, the barrage would be constructed somewhere else. India replied that the answer would be furnished at the next meeting (Source: Transcript of Commission Records, Paragraph: 11.2). Since then, India has not furnished the answer to this question to Bangladesh.

India's unilateral move to construct the Tipaimukh Dam would be a violation of its obligation under the 996 Ganges Water Treaty between Bangladesh and India as well the customary laws of international law governing the utilization of international rivers and lakes. The 1996 thirty-year Ganges Water Sharing Treaty was signed by the heads of state of Bangladesh and India and thus, according to the 1969 Vienna Convention on The Law of Treaties, it has the full backing of international law. Both Bangladesh and India are bound to abide by this treaty until 2026.

The 1996 treaty is the relevant law for assessing the validity of the proposed construction of Tipaimukh or any other structure on shared rivers between Bangladesh and India. The treaty is relevant law because in addition to making provisions for water-sharing in the Ganges, the treaty also enshrines, in Article IX: "Guided by the principles of equity, fairness and no harm to either party both the Governments agree to conclude water sharing Treaties/ Agreements with regard to other common rivers". According to the International Laws Commissions Commentaries on the Draft of 1997 Watercourse Convention, such pledges to apply the principle of equitable utilization and no-harm essentially presupposes obligations of conducting prior consultation and conclusion of agreement with co-basin state before undertaking any planned measures on a common river like the Barak. Accordingly, construction of the Tipaimukh Dam by India on the upstream of Barak which after entering into Bangladesh continues to flow as Kushiara and Surma will be illegal, unless it is preceded by prior consensus with Bangladesh.

As part of the Tipaimukh project, if India builds a barrage over the Barak River, the resulting disastrous consequences on Bangladesh will be a graver violation of the "no harm" principle acknowledged by both countries in the Ganges treaty.


Unilateral construction of the Tipaimukh project would also be inconsistent with the customary laws of international law as reflected in the 1997 UN watercourse convention. This Convention was drafted by the International Law Commission constituted under Article 13(1) of the United Nations Charter. The draft law produced by this Commission represents either existing or emerging rules of international law (ILC Statute, Article 15); several verdicts of the International Court of Justice have already expressed such a view (for example, the 1997 ICJ verdict regarding the River Danube dispute between Hungary and Slovakia).
 
According to the 1997 Convention, a project with the magnitude of impact upon the environment that Tipaimukh will have, cannot be constructed unilaterally by any basin state.. Given that this Convention is ratified by Bangladesh, it could oppose projects like Tipaimukh much more effectively in the international forums or bi-lateral discussions. The 1997 convention emphasizes comprehensive cooperation for equitable utilization of the watercourses, no-harm to any watercourse stares and adequate protection of international watercourses.

In 1992, the Economic Union for Europe devised an even more comprehensive and far-reaching convention regarding utilization and management of transboundary watercourses. By the terms of this convention, there is no scope, at all, to construct structures on joint rivers without conducting a comprehensive environmental impact assessment, providing full information to all the concerned basin- states and ensuring that there are no serious harmful effects on the ecosystem and the co-riparian states.

In the last two decades, various countries in Africa (e.g. 1995 Zambezi River Protocol, 1997 Lake Victoria Program), South East Asia (e.g. 1995 Mekong River Agreement), and South America (e.g. 2004 Program for the Pantanal and Upper Paraguay Program) have all emphasized basin-wide cooperation for ensuring sustainable utilization and management of international watercourses. Even Turkey, known as a country with a low regard for international watercourse law, is now consulting Iraq and Syria about equitable utilization of the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers, in line with the recommendation of the European Parliament on May 20, 2003.

Bangladesh and India are parties to a number of global environmental conventions, which are potentially applicable to the shared natural resources. Among them, Article 3 of Convention on Bio Diversity provides that "States have รข€¦. the responsibility to ensure that activities within their jurisdiction or control do not cause damage to the environment of other states or of areas beyond the limits of national jurisdiction."

The principle is of fundamental importance to international rivers and shared water systems like the Barak Basin as "damaging activities upstream frequently degrade the inland or coastal waters of downstream states".

Provisions for preventing and mitigating harm related with the utilization of shared water systems are also found in a number of conventions including the 1972 Ramsar Convention, the 1992 Framework Convention on Climate change and the 1994 convention on Desertification.

If India decides to ignore the above international rules and norms for undertaking the Tipaimukh project that might prove disastrous for India itself. The sources of several large rivers, such as the Brahmaputra, are in China who is reportedly considering undertaking construction of big dams on some of those rivers. If India claims that there is no international law prohibiting Tipaimukh, then how would India oppose China's projects which would cause serious damage to the environment and economy of India. Indian newspapers are already warning their government about this facet of the problem.

For us, the question is: are we ready to devise the necessary strategies with a holistic vision of the problem?

(Asif Nazrul is a professor of law at the University of Dhaka.. The paper was presented at a recent international conference organised by the International Farakka Committe in Dhaka.)

Confluence Claims Unity

Anti-dam activists in Bangladesh and India have come together to protest against the Tipaimukh dam in Manipur, reports TERESA REHMAN
 
IN MANIPUR'S HMAR dialect, the name for Tipaimukh is 'Ruonglevaisuo', meaning 'the confluence of two rivers'. The two-decade-long struggle against the proposed 1,500 MW Tipaimukh dam project, to be located 500 metres downstream of the confluence of the rivers Trivia and Barak, in Manipur's Churachandpur district has brought about another union – that of anti-dam activists of India and Bangladesh. Activists from both countries, who are regularly in touch through emails and meetings held in Bangladesh, are extremely sceptical of the visit made to the controversial crossborder site by a 10-member Bangla deshi delegation of lawmakers and water resources experts in July this year.
 
According to activists, this first-time visit to the dam site by a Bangladesh team could become a turning point. If construed as a green signal for the dam from the Bangladesh side, it could overturn the long-drawn people's movement against the dam. Activists from both countries came together at the National Tipaimukh Dam Conference (NTDC) organised in Bangladesh this year by an environmental NGO called the Angikar Bangladesh Foundation and are now planning a concerted effort to fight the 163 metre high dam.
 
"Ecology doesn't observe national boundaries. Pakistan and India haven't abrogated the 1960 Indus Treaty despite three wars," says Darryl D'Monte, Presi - dent, International Federation of Envi - ronmental Journalists. Commending activists who are planning to form a joint co-ordinating committee to oppose the Tipaimukh project, D'Monte says, "It makes great sense for environmentalists to join hands across borders — something that politicians seem incapable of doing, because they always see opposing, rather than common, interests".
 
Ramananda Wangkheirakpam, a coordinator of the Manipur-based Citizen's Concern for Dams and Development (CCDD) told TEHELKA that activists' main worry is that the two countries may come to a hurried water-and-powersharing pact, without taking into account the real issues: reduced water flow in the Barak river, destruction of wetlands and farmlands, increased seismicity and destruction of tribal territories in Manipur.
 
"We would like to meet the team from Bangladesh and apprise them of what is happening to other rivers in the Northeast," says Wangkheirakpam. Identified as India's 'future powerhouse', the Northeast is the site of 168 proposed large dams, with a cumulative capacity of 63,328 MW.
 
Activists in Bangladesh draw lessons from the disastrous effect of the Farakka Barrage, built in 1974. Bangladeshi activist Habib Siddiqui refers to the November 1999 Report made by the South Asian Network on Dams, River and People to the World Commission on Dams, which has details about the massive damage the Barrage caused in Malda upstream and Murshidabad downstream.
 
Siddiqui feels that while the initiative to send a delegation is encouraging, it would have better if it included some technical experts as well as members of the opposition party, the BNP. Siddiqui told TEHELKA, "If this dam is constructed, Bangladesh's ecology, agriculture and environment will be severely affected. It must be resisted."
 
Meanwhile, the project has changed hands yet again. On July 15, the Centre replaced power giant North Eastern Electric Power Corporation (NEEPCO) with the National Hydro-electric Power Corporation (NHPC) as the implementing agency. The project will now be a joint venture between NHPC (69 per cent), the Shimla-based Satluj Jal Vidyut Nigam Limited (26 per cent) and the Manipur Government (5 per cent). Earlier with the Brahmaputra Board, the project was awarded to NEEPCO in January 2003.
 
The proposed mega-dam will be the largest hydroelectric project in Eastern India. The project will have a 6 X 250 MW powerhouse. It will take at least 12 years to complete and will submerge 309 sq. km of land. Its consequences have alarmed anti-dam activists. Wangkheirakpam is firm, "We want the project scrapped."
 
Activist mohammad Hilaluddin of Angikar thinks that the Bangladesh delegation's visit highlights the complexity of Bangladesh-India relations. "In April 2009, the Indian foreign secretary visited Bangladesh, which was then reeling from the BDR mutiny and pushed the contentious issue of the Tipaimukh dam construction upon the newly-elected government," he says. The dam-building madness prevailing in the policy-making centres of China and India, says Hilaluddin, must be replaced by collective efforts to prevent a water war.

Thursday, July 23, 2009

US overture to Taliban

EDITORIAL (July 20 2009): In an important foreign policy speech she delivered at the Council of Foreign Relations in Washington the other day, US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton took the position that her country's fight is not with the Taliban but al Qaeda.

Said she, "we and our allies fight in Afghanistan because the Taliban protects al Qaeda, and depends on it for support, sometimes co-ordinating activities." She further said that her side stands ready to welcome anyone supporting the Taliban who renounces al Qaeda, and is willing to participate in the political process. A couple of days earlier, Afghan President Hamid Karzai had made similar remarks, promising "we will be talking with the Taliban, the opponents, solving the problems through talks, if people voted again for me."

These, of course, are well thought-out overtures. Notably, ISPR spokesman Major General Athar Abbas was quoted a few days ago by the CNN as saying that Pakistan was in contact with the Taliban. And that it had the ability to bring Mullah Omer and other commanders like Jalaluddin Haqqani and Gulbadin Hekmatyar to the negotiating table to broker a cease-fire. For some reasons, the ISPR tried to retract General Abbas' claim. But considering Clinton's assertions, the retraction is not so convincing.

The troop surge President Barack Obama had ordered soon after taking over power has not helped his country win the war. The Taliban have been found to be a doggedly determined force; they are often in a position to inflict heavy losses on Western forces.

Earlier this month, Britain's death toll rose to 184. That may look a small number in comparison to the casualties Pakistani soldiers have taken while grappling with the war's spillover from Afghanistan, but it is the highest loss for Britain since World War II. It has triggered severe criticism back in London against the government for its alleged inability to providing the British forces with enough helicopters. As things stand, the word that western diplomats and military commanders use to describe the military situation in Afghanistan is 'stalemate.'

No wonder they have now reached the conclusion that the only way to break the stalemate is to talk in order to end the nearly 8-year long conflict. That is good news for Pakistan, which has paid a heavy price in terms of lives lost - both civilian and military - the nation's economy and its social fabric. Pakistan therefore has as much, if not bigger, a stake in the success of the peace overtures as the US and its allies.

The question is, will they succeed? Former director general of ISI, general Hamid Gul (retd), who is believed to be in touch with the Taliban leadership, comprising mostly his former proteges, thinks that the response would be positive. It is reasonable to think they, too, would be fatigued from fighting for such a long time. It may take a while for the two sides to reach a negotiated settlement, but that is the only way forward.

Copyright Business Recorder, 2009

Eclipse fever in China

BILL SMITH
 
ARTICLE (July 21 2009): As astronomers and amateur stargazers stare heavenward at the total solar eclipse in eastern China on Wednesday, at least one group of visitors, keepers and zoologists will be peering horizontally through the brief blackout at captive animals.

The city zoo in Changzhou, one of the best locations for seeing the total eclipse, will assemble elephants, monkeys and other animals deemed easy to control, to record the animals' reaction to the disturbing changes of light and temperature during the eclipse. The observation at Changzhou zoo is one of scores of special events in China to mark the solar eclipse.

Hundreds of millions of people are expected to watch the eclipse across China, and in India, most of them in major Chinese cities along the Yangzte river valley. "Almost 300 million people live along the total-eclipse belt," Li Jing, a senior researcher at the Chinese Academy of Sciences' National Observatory, told the German Press Agency dpa.

"With the current media publicity, if there is good, sunny weather, then we will see several hundred million people watching," Li said. Ancient astronomers first recorded solar eclipses in China 4,000 years ago. One of the earliest legends concerns an emperor who ordered the execution of two court astronomers accused of failing to predict an eclipse.

A literal meaning of the Chinese characters for a total eclipse is a "complete eating," reflecting primitive belief that a dragon was taking a bite out of the sun or moon during an eclipse. Eclipses were once seen as a portent of doom, with superstitious Chinese believing they were followed by a major natural disaster or the collapse of an imperial dynasty.

Some such superstitions endure in Communist China, especially those linking earthquakes or other natural disasters with political change. But the vast majority of Chinese who watch this week's eclipse will expect nothing more than a once-in-a-lifetime experience of what will be the longest total eclipse this century.

The fact that the eclipse should be clearly visible in 42 major cities, broadly along the Yangtze river valley, has fuelled the excitement in China. A partial eclipse will draw residents of many other cities, including Beijing and Hong Kong, which will see 73-per-cent and 75-per-cent eclipses, respectively.

In Chengdu, the furthest west of those cities, the total eclipse will begin at 9:12 am (0112 GMT) and last for about 3 minutes. Some tourists will climb the 3,000-metre Buddhist holy mountain of Mt Emei, not far from Chengdu, to watch it. Others will go to Mt Putuo, a hill on a small island off the coastal province of Zhejiang south of Shanghai.

But according to weather forecasts, rain and cloud could spoil the party in many of those places, including Shanghai, Hangzhou and Mt Emei. The duration of totality will average at least 5 minutes for most places along the Yangtze in central and eastern coastal areas. The eclipse in Shanghai will last roughly from 8:30 am to 11:30 am, with the total eclipse starting at 9:35 am (0135 GMT) and lasting nearly 6 minutes.

Tour operators are offering trips to Yanshan island and eclipse-watching from cruise ships off the coast of Shanghai. The nearby city of Suzhou, famed for its ancient courtyard houses, gardens and canals, is preparing to host 100,000 Chinese tourists and 10,000 foreign tourists for the eclipse, Wu Min of the Suzhou tourism bureau told state media. "I heard that in the coastal cities, even the school classrooms have been booked," Li said.

US astronomer Jay Pasachoff, head of the International Astronomical Union's Solar Eclipse Working Group, arrived in China in mid-July to prepare for watching the eclipse in Zhejiang's Anji county, state media said. A group of Spanish scientists will provide a live internet broadcast from near the inland city of Chongqing, while state broadcaster China Central Television and the Chinese Academy of Sciences will also show the eclipse live online.

Li said he understood that some leading Indian astronomers planned to watch the eclipse in China rather than in their own country. "Why? Because the time of the eclipse is earlier in India, and the sun will be lower in India than in China, so it is not so advantageous to watch it there," he said. "For professionals, this is a rare chance," Li said. "For example, the Shanghai Observatory is right on the total-eclipse belt, so we can observe it on every waveband with all the equipment ready at hand."

Li said many amateur eclipse-chasers planned to drive around the eclipse belt to ensure a good view. "They even don't book hotel rooms and just drive on the road and spend all their time in their vehicles," he said. "Then if the weather is not good, they can drive to another place with better weather."

Copyright Deutsche Presse-Agentur, 2009

A case for trying Bush and his cohorts

A B SHAHID
ARTICLE (July 22 2009): Recently, while discussing the disbanding of the CIA's 'special' operations cell reporting to former vice president Dick Cheney, Director of US National Intelligence Denis Blair dubbed CIA a 'partner' of "the fellows on the [Capitol] Hill". That's indeed shocking - an intelligence agency being elevated to the level of a partner of the legislature, not subservient to it. What really is the world coming to?

This could happen only in the United States of America - the champion, in fact, self-professed 'imposer' of democracy on the corrupt countries of the second and third worlds. By itself, and in its unadulterated form, democracy is the least bad system of governance. That it has malfunctioned globally in the last quarter of a century is indeed a challenge to its survival but not one that threatens its extinction.

But what turn democracy (not immune to corruption) into a joke are the revelations about its incapacity to keep in check the likes of George Bush and Dick Cheney, and an army of operatives at the CIA, who knowingly commit downright criminal acts because they are told that those acts have been authorised by the fellows at Capitol Hill - specialists in sanctifying the holiness of the pursuit of "US national interests".

The worst scenario surfaces when, over time, the intelligence agencies become the law unto themselves by sidelining or defying the legislature and the state, with the blessings of a top ranking insider at the Capitol Hill (like Cheney), or independently (like FBI's J. Edgar Hoover and CIA's Allen Dulles). Such tragedies destroy confidence in democracy that promises goodies like independent legislatures, law-making and accountability.

To Mathew Smith (author of "The Kennedys - the conspiracy to destroy a dynasty" published in May 2005) the assassination of the Kennedy brothers, is a continuing story of "the determination of a handful of people to control the governance of America...... the worrying factor in this story is that this poison has not been expelled [from the system]. It is something still remaining to be done".

The main reason there for is the legacy of controversies that each US head of state carried with him making him vulnerable to blackmailing by the powerful intelligence agencies. The Kennedys too had their share of controversies. That's why, even though after the Bay of Pigs fiasco President Kennedy had strictly forbidden any covert action to assassinate Cuba's Fidel Castro, the CIA went on organising such efforts.

There were hopes that Obama - without a controversial track record - may begin 'expelling' that poison from the system. Instead, by assuring everyone at the CIA that he or she won't be held responsible for what Chris McGreal calls "years of torture, abductions and killings, along with the mass surveillance of Americans conducted under dubious legal authorisations" he too appears to have fallen by the way side.

The scenario has been made worse by the fact that the CIA is trying to defy all attempts at seeking disclosure of full facts about the 8-year long activities of its special cell, saying "it has been disbanded". The admission that it was organised only to assassinate Bin Laden is a poor cover-up because, according to highly respected columnist Seymour Hersh, the targets of this squad were more diverse.

What isn't being realised is that such cover-ups give credence to rumours about even those covert operations that are pure fabrications. Therefore poorly planned cover-ups are hardly the route to re-building confidence in the sovereignty of the US parliament, and exposing those who go on adding horrible shades to that image. It is time Dick Cheney and George Bush were exposed fully and given the treatment they deserve.

That's the only way to re-build US image and to show the world that criminals can't go scot free in America, no matter who they are. That America is governed by a set of fair and enlightened rules of governance that do justice to one and all. That America punishes those who violate internationally accepted codes of conduct. That pursuit of US interests at the expense of other nations is not the philosophy of the state any more.

This is imperative for ending the conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq (the cooked-up WMD affair) and diluting anti-US feelings for killing millions (finally admitted by Adm. Mullen). The US must admit these blunders of the Bush regime. Admittedly, for the overly self-righteous but uninformed Americans it won't be easy to admit blunders, but the alternative is slow yet assured self-destruction via bankruptcy - a stark reality now.

In spite of the propaganda by the Bush administration, which was ably assisted by the Zionist-dominated US media, the world hasn't forgotten that in the post-9/11 scenario, Taliban - Afghan rulers at the time - had declared sympathy with the Americans who died and voted for Bin Laden and al Qaeda to be told to leave Afghanistan. It was a plea for patience on the part of the US, which was ignored by the Bush-Cheney clan.

Afghan reaction was hardly an expression of defiance of America that had trained many Afghans to fight the Russians. It was an opportunity to turn the Taliban against al Qaeda. Instead, the Bush-led America attacked Afghanistan only to cement Afghan alliance with al Qaeda and make a monster like Bin laden a hero. It was not just a blunder; it was a grave crime committed by self-seekers against the US that shattered its image.

Should Obama cover-up this blunder, or for a change, should he insist that mistakes be admitted and justice done? As a black American he has made history by rising to the top in a white-dominated society. He must also prove that he is not from the ranks of those who forgave the likes of Johnson, Nixon and Bush Senior for the disaster brought on the US by their dumb ventures in Vietnam, Cambodia, Afghanistan and Iraq.

As of now, there are no signs of such a courageous stand being taken by Obama. He doesn't realise that by trying Bush, Cheney and their cohorts in the State Department, the CIA and the Pentagon, he will prove to the world that America stands for justice and sanity, and tell Iran that it can't go on projecting itself as the sole defender of these values - something that continues to intoxicate the politically limping Ahmedinejad.

Obama needs more than articulate speeches to put a house in order that remained in the grip of self-seekers for nearly four decades. Politicians propped up by the corrupt and the greed-driven in the US corporate sector, have left behind a legacy that can't be undone by 'bail-out' packages alone. Americans don't only need to eat and live comfortably but, far more than that, need to re-learn the difference between right and wrong.

Obama needs to set an historic example thereof by trying George Bush, Cheney and their cohorts, for their crimes against the much adored US interests, if not against humanity. If warmongers from Cambodia, Congo, Liberia, Rwanda, and Yugoslavia can be tried by the International Court of Justice, Bush and Cheney can be tried for war crimes within the US; it will raise America's stature to what it was under Abraham Lincoln.

Copyright Business Recorder, 2009